Board Thread:Voting/@comment-30450022-20180123033016

Since the whole "Rockabillykitty" incident, I've been thinking, and I have some new propositions to the wiki that I'm wondering if you guys would like to see.

If you haven't heard about the whole drama, Rockabillykitty made a video featuring our wiki. In the video, she showed disbelief that some items were worth certain things (e.g. RIMs being worth spikes). A lot of hate against us broke out in the comment section, and we went in to try to defend ourselves.

Apparently, a lot of people hate our wiki because "our values are inaccurate." What a lot of people don't understand is that we have collector's values as our rarities on most pages.

That got me thinking: why do we need the collector's value? Sure, it might be what a couple people are willing to trade for it, but not that many people are going to trade a black long for a rare giant lion plushie.

So, here are the options I laid out for us:

A. Keep everything the way it is, the Uncommon template is fine

B. Remove the template entirely and replace the collector values with community values

C. Remove the template entirely and keep the collector values

D. Keep the template but add in an option for both collector and community values (like this:)



E. Replace the collector value with the community value and change the template to something that says "This is an uncommon item, and collectors are known to trade more for this item than what is given here."

F. Other (comment your ideas below) 